« Newer Older »

Panic's Pretty. Odd. is pretty freakin' fabulous: Buzznet album review


If I start every one of my reviews off by declaring my undying love for said CD, you might start to question my taste. But you know what? I'll take that chance. I f----ing love Panic at the Disco's Pretty. Odd.

Now, the real obstacle is listening to this disc objectively — that is, clear away all the "boo hoo it's not Fever and it's a blatant Beatles rip-off" commentary that has been flying about the past week or so.

If Ryan Ross hadn't confessed to having a love affair with Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, would you even have considered the comparison? I mean, really — where were you during the Beatles craze? Were you but a mere sparkle in your mother's eye? I'm thinking your mother was barely a sparkle in your grandmother's eye. The point is Beatlemania was a WHILE ago. Even if I thought they were replicating their sound, I'd still be stoked, because there are worse bands to be influenced by. Nickleback, for example.



I realize that the testosterone boys and harlequin girls feel that they can't properly extract sexually energetic phrases to describe blooming egos and ever-developing teen angst. May I suggest… rap?

A Fever You Can’t Sweat Out was like hanging out with your super-articulate yet slightly melodramatic crush (who just wouldn’t stop talking). Pretty. Odd. Is your tree-hugging, laid-back, perma-positive buddy — your good influence (even if he does eat the special brownies).

Panic at the Disco may not have found their signature sound yet, but I'm willing to tag along with them while they explore.

Best song to create new AIM screen names from:  "She Had the World"
Best song to convert your parents: "Folkin’ Around"
Best songs to slide across a hardwood floor in your socks while singing into a hairbrush microphone: "Pas De Cheval" and "Mad as Rabbits"

Linkage:
Reaction round up is over here!
Kron reviews the new Raconteurs.
Mark reviews A Silver Mt. Zion's latest.
Put your reviews in our super-fantastic album review group!

Related Groups: Buzznet Album Reviews
Posted on 03/25/2008 5:11 AM Visits: 660
ArianneGibson: 03/24/2008 7:35 PM
i didnt even know Ryan confessed to loving Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, its just really obvious that, that was what they were going for.
Neil Patrick Harris: 03/24/2008 7:35 PM
I perfectly agree with this interview.
I love Pretty.Odd, but then again I'm a Beatles fan.
And I didn't know that Ryan was listening to SPLHCB. I knew he was going to back to classic music, the Beatles being one of those bands, but I immediately thought of the foremention album with a really long name when I heard it.
It just needs its theme song.
Neil Patrick Harris: 03/24/2008 7:36 PM
I hate spelling errors.
I meant aforementioned, in case you didn't know.
And review.
Aghh.
I'm just gonna get off now/
decaydance10: 03/24/2008 7:36 PM
"even if he does eat the special brownies" hahaha lmao
i can't wait to listen to it! i waited...
ArianneGibson: 03/24/2008 7:38 PM
but i'm all for them changing, they were pretty young when Fever was released. I think they're just out of that teen, hormonal phase, ya know?
AudreyEllen: 03/24/2008 7:44 PM
I can't wait to buy it!
and see them in concert.
symbolicfishlovproductions728: 03/24/2008 7:46 PM
i have listened to it adn i completely disagree. i think the only songs that are decent are pas de cheval, mad as rabbits, adn that green gentleman. i don't like the rest of them. sorry to disagree with you, but i must express my dissapointment after hearing this album
Johnson Is Love Girl:): 03/24/2008 7:49 PM
Tomorrow is my BIG day! The album comes out and I turn 20 years old! I'm ready to rock and sing and love Panic more!
ArianneGibson: 03/24/2008 7:53 PM
I hate spelling errors. I meant aforementioned, in case you didn't know. And review.Aghh.I'm just gonna get off now/
im confused haha
gemmaxloves: 03/24/2008 8:03 PM
i listened to it with no preconceptions and still can't get into it, but then again i didn't like sgt peppers lonely hearts, even though i do like the beatles
i think its too heavily influenced and even if you didn't know about the love of the beatles its obvious
its too mish-mashy
i'm going to give it another whirl on repeat see if i can start to get into it, but it doesn't look good

its a shame because i want to like it =[
dizz02: 03/24/2008 9:05 PM
I didnt even read what ryan said about having a love affair with sgt peppers lonely hearts.
but i totally got a beatles vibe from it anyway.
Which is a good thing cuz im digging that stuff at the moment
especially from ryans voice.
personally i think its a cool laid back album.
Different from their last which shows their range.
Maybe not be everyones taste but they can reach a new audience with this.
Erica Owens: 03/24/2008 10:09 PM
The Beatles are so legendary and iconic that it's hard to "pay homage" to their sound without it coming across as a bad rip off...at least I think so. There's a difference between "Panic channeling their inner beatles and using it in their own way to create a sound thats reminiscent of the beatles but obviously still Panic At The Disco...."all I hear is rip off (in most cases). A Fever You Can't Sweat Out was in my opinion one of the most original sounding mainstream pop rock albums in a while! That is what made me want to listen to them. That's what made me say, wow, Ryan Ross can write a great song. Sure, they were obviously influenced by certain things on their last album and it came across but it never sounded like a rip off of anything else!

sorry this was so long. :-(
sharkattacksam: 03/25/2008 4:19 AM
I completely agree to everything you say, I'm fed up of all the Beatles remarks I have heard over the past few weeks, so what?!?! I think the Beatles would be honored, if Paul McCartney heard it I bet he would feel proud that a band that he was a part of had inspired a band that so many people of this generation love, hell I know I would be!
So yeah I agree with you =], well said!
Also, this album shows a completely different aspect of the band, they can have songs about being a teenager but they can have magical/wonderland feel songs and it shows what sort of band they are, and for that I love Panic At The Disco!
Adriana: 03/25/2008 5:31 AM
Yes, that's the whole idea right there: "Panic at the Disco may not have found their signature sound yet, but I'm willing to tag along with them while they explore." Agree! And good point, with the Beatles thing...
morganjade: 03/25/2008 5:31 AM
The new album is great. I dont think they have ripped of anyone, especially the beatles, who caresif they sound a little like them? panic aren't ripping them off. What i'm hating though is Beatles fans, who don't like panic, bitching about panic because they have heard it sounds like a beatles album, its like "hello! its called an influence!" nobody can create the same sound the beatles did, panic are making something new, if they wanted to be the beatles, they would have made a cover album.

sorry if this doesn't make sense, im annoyed @ it all
Total: 134 1 2 3 4 5 6 7... 9
Add a Comment
Name Email

 
Sign Up or Sign In to have your picture next to your comment.
ARCHIVE
'your mom' jokes or jack barakat's mom?
warped tour or taste of chaos?
tumblr or livejournal?
MY FRIENDS


Breesays' Journal Widgets:
RSS | ATOM | JavaScript
Buzz Feed